‘Filth has nowhere to hide?’


Signs are very powerful forms of communication in our society. They send us messages that can be interpreted differently by many different audiences. This can be due to personal values, social groups, or cultural influences.

This image sparks an interesting discussion, mainly in the fact that the advertisement is for a cleaning product but depicts a very different image. Upon initial viewing, the denotation of the image is that the floor is shiny and clean as a result of using the cleaning product. Our eyes are then directed to the shiny floor in the middle of the picture, where upon further inspection of the reflection we can see a man and a young schoolgirl seemingly ‘talking’.

The girl is dressed in innocent school clothes, and the man well dressed in suit pants and a button up shirt. By suggesting that the man is much older than the girl and placing them together in a bedroom, something already seems off. The room is very bare and dull, and if not for the reflection it would look much more gloomy. When we closely look at the reflection, the mysterious man has come into contact with the girl and is handing her some money. The connotations surrounding this image are that the girl is a prostitute, and that the man is paying her for her services. If we look to the right, we can see that his shoes are on the floor, implying that he hasn’t had his shoes on for a period of time, further inferring that a sexual act may have taken place. This theory is reinforced as the girl is slightly lifting up her skirt, giving a somewhat sexual enticement towards the man.

When an audience first glances at this image, a feeling of innocence is definitely present. One can not be discouraged for first thinking; ‘this is a teacher talking to a student after class’ or ‘maybe a father talking to his daughter in her bedroom after a day at school.’ However, once the viewer realises the real meaning of this image, it can never be unseen. The creators used different angles and reflections in the image so that readers have to look many times to understand the true message behind it. The sheer reality of this image is what makes it so powerful, engaging the viewer and demanding a more in- depth look at the advertisement.

Garth Burley.

References: http://static.businessinsider.com/image/5138cc2feab8eaf95a000013/image.jpg (accessed 20/3/15)


2 thoughts on “‘Filth has nowhere to hide?’

  1. Great post Garth. I love the way you’ve looked at the possible interpretations of the image “maybe a father talking to his daughter in her bedroom after a day at school.” I certainly agree this image and many others require an in depth analysis. Looking forward to more posts.


  2. You have chosen a great image for this blog Mr Burley. My first reaction to the image was ‘that’s a shiny floor’ though the more I look at the image the more layers I uncover. Your connotations of the image are exactly what I saw though with a different context I could see how a viewer could see the idea of a father talking to his daughter.
    The briefcase stands out to me in the image because I believe that provides the notion of the age difference when you compare that to the school uniform the girl is wearing. So that could have been another part of the image you could of used to back up your connotations of prostitution.
    Also maybe a little more of a definition around signs and semiotics would of provided readers with more depth and the use of articles to back up your points made. I used this article by Michael Danesi http://www.oxfordbibliographies.com/view/document/obo-9780199756841/obo-9780199756841-0050.xml, which looked at modern definitions and articles about semiotics.
    Overall Garth, very interesting blog with a great image and amusing ironic title to match. Keep up the good blogs, looking forward to many more.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s